2001 Civil Opinions (Part 1)
Documents may require Adobe Reader. Please read the
Document Tips
before accessing documents!
2001-0007:
Pazos v. Lyondell - 12/21/2001
2001-0008:
Brenner v. Harleysville Ins. - 09/30/2002
2001-0011:
Hamilton v. Travelers - 05/11/2001
2001-0013:
Rose v. Lehigh - 09/14/2001
2001-0015:
Haysel v. Hertz - 06/18/2001
2001-0022:
Levitz v. Nationwide - 04/11/2001
2001-0050:
Ryales v. Phoenixville - 11/16/2001
2001-0053:
Jordan v. CCH - 10/07/2002
2001-0066:
Ginsberg v. Independence - 03/16/2001
2001-0075:
DiPasquale v. Bensalem Twp. - 11/06/2001
2001-0078:
Traverlers v. Ward - 09/20/2002
2001-0079:
Dubin v. Principal - 04/23/2001
2001-0079:
Dubin v. Principal - 05/15/2001
2001-0081:
Rolan v. Vaughn - 10/13/2004
2001-0083:
Nolan v. Cooper - 03/14/2001
2001-0086:
Harper v. Kyler - 04/22/2005
2001-0114:
Pena v. Walter - 10/02/2001
2001-0119:
Lee v. A.R.T. - 05/11/2001
2001mc130:
In Re: Armstrong - 07/10/2001
2001-0134:
Morgon v. Wendy's - 12/14/2001
2001-0145:
Franklin v. NY Times - 08/16/2001
2001-0145:
Franklin v. NY Times - 06/19/2003
2001-0145:
Franklin v. NY Times - 08/05/2004
2001-0150:
Johnson v. Philadelphia - 03/09/2001
2001mc151:
Northwestern v. Travelers - 09/20/2001
2001mc151:
Northwestern v. Travelers - 11/08/2001
2001mc156:
Terminix v. Barbieri - 10/15/2001
2001-0157:
Innovative v. Global - 07/13/2001
2001-0159:
Smithkline Beecham v. Apotex - 09/28/2005
2001-0159:
Smithkline Beecham v. Apotex - 12/30/2005
2001-0159:
SmithKline Beecham v. Apotex - 01/31/2006
2001-0176:
Guldner v. Wellman - 07/26/2001
2001-0179:
Clean Air v. Mallory - 10/18/2002
2001-0192:
Gharzouzi v. Northwestern Human Services - 05/07/2002
2001-0197:
Idasetima v. Wabash Metal - 11/29/2001
2001-0203:
U.S.A. v. Leuthe - 03/21/2002
2001mc205:
EEOC v. Guess - 12/27/2001
2001-0221:
Straight Arrow v. Conversion - 12/03/2001
2001-0223:
Thompson v. Fare - 11/21/2001
2001-0224:
Schalliol v. Fare - 06/07/2002
2001-0231:
P & M Products v. Rose Art Ind. - 03/21/2002
2001-0242:
Guiteras v. Barnhart - 02/22/2002
2001-0258:
Novick v. Unumprovident - 07/12/2001
2001-0259:
In Re: Jadusingh - 04/10/2001
2001-0263:
Ingram v. Barnhart - 01/16/2002
2001-0272:
U.S.A. v. Ullman - 10/31/2001
2001-0272:
U.S.A. v. Ullman - 05/08/2002
2001-0274:
Runner v. Fleming - 05/18/2001
2001-0279:
Bees v. Vaughn - 07/16/2002
2001-0287:
Walsh v. Alarm - 08/01/2001
2001-0287:
Walsh v. Alarm - 10/23/2002
2001-0288:
Galligan v. Philadelphia - 05/15/2001
2001-0298:
Crespo-Medina v. Danzig - 09/24/2001
2001-0302:
National R.R. v. PPUC - 05/10/2001
2001-0314:
Czubryt v. Consolidated Rail - 02/21/2002
2001-0337:
Gerhart v. Merck & Co. - 12/10/2001
2001-0351:
Caleb v. CRST - 04/30/2001
2001-0361:
The Travelers v. Schmalz - 12/17/2001
2001-0363:
Phillips v. Selig - 03/29/2001
2001-0375:
Brown v. K-Mart - 04/24/2001
2001-0382:
Sprague v. ABA - 04/11/2001
2001-0382:
Sprague v. ABA - 11/14/2001
2001-0405:
Patel v. Zemski - 05/11/2001
2001-0408:
Bonneville v. Peters - 08/01/2001
2001-0419:
Bacone v. P.H.A. - 06/27/2001
2001-0419:
Bacone v. P.H.A. - 05/07/2003
2001-0420:
Smith v. National - 08/13/2001
2001-0421:
Goldstein v. Street - 07/09/2001
2001-0425:
Donnelly v. State Farm - 02/28/2001
2001-0428:
Wheeler v. Vaughn - 01/06/2004
2001-0430:
Caucci v. Prison Health - 05/10/2001
2001-0431:
Grimm v. Borough of Norristown - 03/11/2002
2001-0431:
Grimm v. Borough of Norristown - 04/09/2002
2001-0431:
Grimm v. Sweeney - 03/10/2003
2001-0451:
US Fidelity v. Smith - 11/09/2001
2001-0457:
Evans v. U.S.A. - 06/26/2001
2001-0457:
Evans v. U.S.A. - 08/06/2001
2001-0459:
Freeman v. Ciao - 05/25/2001
2001-0468:
Turicentro v. American - 07/26/2001
2001-0476:
Merriweather v. Phila. Fed. - 06/19/2001
2001-0476:
Merriweather v. Phila. Fed. - 11/07/2001
2001-0477:
Baselice v. Phila. Fed. Teachers Fund - 05/01/2002
2001-0481:
Goldstein v. Timoney - 02/20/2001
2001-0490:
Cinalli v. Kane - 03/15/2002
2001-0507:
Batts v. Halter - 05/03/2002
2001-0522:
In Re: U.S. Interactive - 08/23/2002
2001-0539:
Pippett v. Waterford - 07/31/2001
2001-0553:
Windsor Jewels of PA v. Bristol Twp - 02/11/2005
2001-0562:
Henderson v. Barnhart - 11/05/2002
2001-0568:
Dorsey v. Shannon - 07/17/2003
2001-0578:
Walker v. Fisher (1) - 07/12/2002
2001-0578:
Walker v. Fisher (2) - 01/21/2005
2001-0602:
L. v. Lower Merion School District - 04/02/2002
2001-0610:
Atamian v. Maslund - 07/06/2001
2001-0612:
Bethea v. Bristol Lodge - 12/19/2002
2001-0623:
Rainey v. Varner - 02/21/08
2001-0626:
Cordero v. Faulkner - 03/05/2002
2001-0627:
Adams v. Kyler - 08/16/2002
2001-0627:
Adams v. Kyler - 05/03/2005
2001-0628:
National Grange v. Sharp Equipment - 03/04/2002
2001-0650:
Canonica v. Dept of Defense - 07/18/2002
2001-0660:
McKenna v. Sanford Meisner - 07/19/2001
2001-0686:
Jackman v. City of Philadelphia - 04/03/2002
2001-0691:
Berwyn Capital Investments v. Shore Venture Group - 02/14/2006
2001-0691:
Berwyn Capital Investments v. Shore Venture Group - 05/01/2006
2001-0691:
Berwyn Capital Investments v. Shore Venture Group - 06/19/2006
2001-0691:
Berwyn Capital Investments v. Shore Venture Group - 07/18/2006
2001-0703:
Samuel-Bassett v. Kia - 05/11/2001
2001-0703:
Samuel-Bassett v. Kia - 12/16/2002
2001-0740:
Coombs v. 3rd Circuit - 04/26/2001
2001-0751:
Cymphus v. Vishay - 05/25/2001
2001-0757:
Lowery v. Great Lakes - 07/19/2001
2001-0759:
Reed v. Weeks - 08/21/2001
2001-0770:
Heather D. v. Northampton Area School District - 06/19/2007
2001-0784:
Motorist Mutual v. Phoenix - 10/24/2001
2001-0785:
Varallo v. Elkins Park Hospital - 03/19/2002
2001-0788:
Brown v. Shannon - 05/30/2002
2001-0809:
Yacoub v. Elwood - 01/14/2002
2001-0816:
Siemens v. Carmelengo - 04/12/2001
2001-0834:
W.G. Nicols v. Ferguson - 06/07/2002
2001-0835:
Galloway v. Southwark - 10/28/2003
2001-0854:
Auerbach v. Kantor-Curley - 12/30/2004
2001-0857:
James v. Allentown Business School - 06/02/2003
2001-0871:
Choates v. Halter - 03/27/2007
2001-0874:
McCusker v. Penn Fuel Gas - 07/11/2003
2001-0882:
Pittman v. Transport - 11/01/2001
2001-0882:
Pittman v. Transport - 11/01/2001
2001-0902:
Nutrition Management v. Harborside Healthcare - 11/30/2004
2001-0902:
Nutrition Management v. Harborside Healthcare - 05/17/2005
2001-0905:
Vogt v. Time Warner - 04/05/2001
2001-0912:
Tomoney v. Warden - 07/17/2002
2001-0924:
White v. Ottinger - 08/09/2006
2001-0950:
Lamb v. North Wales - 11/16/2001
2001-0959:
Press v. Massanari - 01/16/2002
2001-0962:
Quarles v. Lineberger - 03/21/2002
2001-0962:
Quarles v. Lineberger - 03/27/2002
2001-0962:
Quarles v. Lineberger - 05/05/2003
2001-0966:
Cherry v. Philadelphia - 02/28/2002
2001-0973:
Beasley v. Hartman - 11/05/2002
2001-0979:
Century 21 v. Digennaro - 01/31/2002
2001-0987:
Frazier v. Hairston - 08/23/2001
2001-0991:
Professional v. Bridgeview - 09/13/2001
2001-0994:
American v. Upper Dublin - 05/20/2002
2001-1004:
Thompson v. Merck - 01/11/2007
2001-1008:
Kennelly v. PA Turnpike - 06/19/2002
2001-1018:
Fiori v. Rockford - 06/21/2006
2001-1030:
Hay v. GMAC (1) - 09/15/2003
2001-1030:
Hay v. GMAC (2) - 09/15/2003
2001-1033:
Metro v. Cairone - 09/27/2001
2001-1045:
Washington v. Vaughn - 06/03/2002
2001-1064:
Hemphill v. Massanari - 04/05/2002
2001-1067:
G/Q Studios v. McAdams - 05/29/2003
2001-1071:
Gambone v. Advanced Construction Material - 11/09/2005
2001-1072:
Dorsey v. Provident - 10/05/2001
2001-1072:
Dorsey v. Provident - 10/05/2001
2001-1073:
Price v. Pennsylvania - 06/06/2001
2001-1083:
Kammann v. Max Levy Autograph - 01/31/2002
2001-1100:
McNeil-PPC v. L. Perrigo - 06/25/2002
2001-1112:
Fetterolf v. Harcourt General - 12/18/2001
2001-1116:
Ryales v. Pilling Weck - 06/24/2002
2001-1118:
Bolles v. K-Mart - 07/09/2001
2001-1128:
Kahhan v. Massachusetts - 11/14/2001
2001-1163:
Prifti v. PNC Bank - 10/09/2001
2001-1178:
Martin v. Warrington - 03/04/2002
2001-1179:
Brasch v. U.S.A. - 10/29/2001
2001-1183:
Wolf v. Phila. School District - 06/20/2002
2001-1189:
In Re: Cell Pathways - 07/26/2001
2001-1189:
In Re: Cell Pathways - 09/24/2002
2001-1203:
Mitchell v. Yeadon Borough - 02/22/2002
2001-1204:
First Union v. Bank One, N.A. - 04/01/2002
2001-1207:
Conchatta v. Col. Paul J. Evanko - 02/23/2005
2001-1211:
State Farm v. Ciccarella - 05/01/2002
2001-1220:
LaFata v. Raytheon - 03/21/2002
2001-1220:
LaFata v. Raytheon - 08/27/2002
2001-1220:
LaFata v. Raytheon - 02/03/2004
2001-1229:
Kolar v. Rite Aid - 03/11/2003
2001-1234:
R&B v. Needa - 08/13/2001
2001-1234:
R&B v. Needa - 08/23/2005
2001-1242:
Thakur v. R.W. Johnson - 06/25/2003
2001-1252:
Lark v. Beard - 05/24/2006
2001-1252:
Lark v. Beard - 07/03/2007
2001-1259:
Imbesi v. Imbesi - 10/30/2001
2001-1270:
Green v. Associates Commercial - 03/04/2002
2001-1270:
Green v. Associated Commercial - 02/05/2003
2001-1289:
EMC Global v. Alavezos - 05/08/2001
2001-1302:
Versar v. Ball - 07/12/2001
2001-1303:
American Library v. U.S.A. - 03/26/2001
2001-1303:
American Library v. U.S.A. - 05/31/2002
2001-1306:
Cook v. General - 08/06/2001
2001-1312:
Willis v. Chase Manhattan - 09/14/2001
2001-1322:
Multnomah County Public Library v. U.S.A. - 05/31/2002
2001-1333:
Edwards v. Wyatt - 07/31/2001
2001-1333:
Edwards v. Wyatt - 11/06/2001
2001-1333:
Edwards v. Wyatt - 08/05/2002
2001-1333:
Edwards v. Wyatt - 07/14/2004
2001-1333:
Edwards v. Wyatt - 10/13/2006
2001-1333:
Edwards v. Wyatt - 01/16/2007
2001-1342:
McGrogan v. SEPTA - 07/19/2002
2001-1347:
Tarlecki v. Mercy - 07/16/2002
2001-1372:
Branson v. Barnhart - 12/29/2005
2001-1385:
In Re: Dulisse - 07/05/2001
2001-1395:
Borel v. Panichevich - 12/04/2001
2001-1396:
KP v. Prentiss - 04/27/2001
2001-1402:
Blanck v. Exeter School District - 10/02/2002
2001-1410:
Ayala v. Superintendent S.C.I. - 02/08/2002
2001-1419:
Pennco v. Tornos - 04/18/2001
2001-1442:
In Re: J.E. Brenneman - 03/18/2003
2001-1475:
Sunoco v. Praxair - 04/30/2001
2001-1479:
Clark v. City of Coatesville - 10/23/2001
2001-1494:
Allen v. Vaughn - 06/19/2002
2001-1518:
McCrane v. Marconi Medical - 03/28/2002
2001-1519:
Feldman v. Kay & Son's - 11/01/2001
2001-1523:
Grant v. Kingswood - 10/02/2001
2001-1523:
Grant v. Kingswood - 12/18/2001
2001-1523:
Grant v. Kingswood - 10/15/2001
2001-1532:
Meltzer v. Continental - 09/13/2001
2001-1557:
Mawhinney v. GMAC - 04/02/2002
2001-1559:
Maydwell v. Yoffe - 06/21/2001
2001-1570:
McComb v. Neumann - 07/18/2001
2001-1584:
Torres v. Thompson - 08/01/2003
2001-1605:
Lawman v. Winner - 01/28/2002
2001-1606:
IN RE: Thomas W. Olick & Kathryn Olick - 03/19/2002
2001-1607:
IN RE: Thomas W. Olick & Kathryn Olick - 03/19/2002
2001-1611:
Levere v. Barnhart - 03/15/2002
2001-1613:
Siemans v. Camacho - 04/18/2001
2001-1622:
Hankin Family v. Upper Merion Twp. - 03/22/2002
2001-1622:
Timoney v. Upper Merion Twp. - 12/08/2004
2001-1657:
McFarlene v. Gillis - 12/13/2007
2001-1658:
Tecmarine v. CSX - 08/13/2001
2001-1658:
Tecmarine v. CSX - 10/17/2001
2001-1661:
Pro-Spice v. Omni - 09/20/2001
2001-1663:
Perlmutter v. Pettus - 10/02/2001
2001-1670:
Hansberry v. Philadelphia - 10/24/2002
2001-1676:
Harper v. American Red Cross - 07/17/2001
2001-1678:
Young v. Philadelphia - 08/27/2001
2001-1710:
Murphy v. Volta - 05/15/2002
2001-1717:
Levin v. Great American - 12/04/2001
2001-1720:
Teti v. Villanova - 10/24/2001
2001-1720:
Teti v. Villanova - 01/23/2003
2001-1723:
Winters v. Savings Plan - 08/13/2001
2001-1733:
Senick v. United Transportation - 11/27/2001
2001-1736:
Apt v. Massanari - 11/28/2001
2001-1760:
DeFelice v. Daspin - 06/25/2002
2001-1760:
DeFelice v. Daspin - 09/18/2002
2001-1764:
Misavage v. Barnhart - 02/22/2002
2001-1789:
Kelly v. Retirement - 07/11/2002
2001-1798:
Ryan v. Lower Merion Twp. - 06/12/2002
2001-1799:
Mason v. Abington Twp. Police Depart. - 09/12/2002
2001-1807:
Robinson v. May Department Stores - 02/12/2003
2001-1825:
Alifano v. Merck - 12/10/2001
2001-1876:
Chester v. Fredericksdorf - 10/10/2001
2001-1895:
Berger v. Scott - 07/26/2001
2001-1896:
In Re: Penn Treaty - 05/15/2002
2001-1898:
Strozyk v. Norfolk - 07/18/2001
2001-1911:
Smith v. Haggerty - 10/04/2001
2001-1919:
Kol Ami v. Abington Twp. - 07/11/2001
2001-1919:
Kol Ami v. Abington Twp. - 08/17/2004
2001-1923:
National v. Tartaglione - 10/11/2001
2001-1923:
National v. Tartaglione - 10/22/2001
2001-1931:
Brown v. Paul Revere - 05/20/2002
2001-1940:
Santiago v. Walters - 12/18/2001
2001-1950:
Amsan v. Prophet - 10/16/2001
2001-1953:
Morris v. First Union - 01/14/2002
2001-1986:
Davila v. Master - 08/12/2002
2001-1993:
Law v. SEPTA - 06/18/2001
2001-1997:
Graham v. Kyler - 11/01/2002
2001-2017:
Turton v. Sharp - 07/19/2001
2001-2023:
Shubert v. Roche - 08/03/2001
2001-2030:
Bobbi v. Dole - 05/01/2001
2001-2037:
Seaton v. Univ. of Penn. - 11/30/2001
2001-2039:
Ortiz v. Burnham - 01/11/2002
2001-2049:
Schwartz v. Liberty Mutual - 12/18/2001
2001-2075:
Mobile v. SI - 08/01/2001
2001-2097:
C. v. Phila. School District - 01/24/2003
2001-2099:
In Re: Commerce Construction - 03/20/2003
2001-2141:
Atkinson v. Lafayette College - 01/30/2002
2001-2153:
Greene v. Sharpe - 11/20/2001
2001-2156:
Keown v. Richfood - 06/19/2002
2001-2158:
Benigno v. Flatley - 09/17/2001
2001-2158:
Benigno v. Flatley - 01/30/2002
2001-2167:
Cruz v. Northwest Airlines - 03/05/2002
2001-2167:
Cruz v. NW Airlines - 10/18/2002
2001-2169:
Smithkline Beecham v. Apotex - 09/28/2005
2001-2169:
Smithkline Beecham v. Apotex - 12/30/2005
2001-2169:
SmithKline Beecham v. Apotex - 01/31/2006
2001-2172:
Hand v. American Board of Surgery - 02/14/2002
2001-2172:
Hand v. American Board of Surgery - 04/24/2002
2001-2178:
Rambert v. Varner - 07/17/2002
2001-2180:
In Re: Resource America - 08/08/2001
2001-2191:
Argonaut v. Phil's Tavern - 10/30/2001
2001-2196:
Layden v. HSL Builders - 06/26/2002
2001-2197:
In Re: Amin A. Rashid - 01/08/2002
2001-2201:
Tenet v. PA Nurses - 12/20/2001
2001-2202:
English Sports v. Tostigan - 03/18/2002
2001-2202:
English Sports v. Tostigan - 03/18/2002
2001-2213:
Beatson-Locke v. Kmart - 11/20/2001
2001-2223:
Checkpoint Systems v. All-Tag Security - 01/25/2007
2001-2223:
Checkpoint Systems v. All-Tag Security - 02/20/2007
2001-2232:
Jones v. Barnhart - 03/26/2002
2001-2270:
Evans v. William Penn - 05/15/2002
2001-2279:
Manning v. Blaine - 11/21/2001
2001-2281:
Swinehart v. McAndrews - 08/15/2002
2001-2307:
Seneca v. New Hope Borough - 02/27/2002
2001-2311:
Johnson v. King Media - 06/24/2002
2001-2323:
Cordova v. Barnhart - 06/19/2002
2001-2341:
Baxter v. Melendez - 04/03/2002
2001-2350:
Carlin v. Jacobs - 09/17/2001
2001-2361:
Walls v. Barnhart - 03/28/2002
2001-2385:
Reid v. Vaughn - 03/04/2003
2001-2385:
Reid v. Vaughn - 05/02/2003
2001-2394:
Medmarc v. Arrow - 07/29/2002
2001-2394:
Medmarc v. Arrow - 02/05/2003
2001-2427:
Grier v. Barnhart - 05/07/2002
2001-2430:
Veress v. Alumax - 05/20/2002
2001-2431:
Burgos v. Vaughn - 01/12/2006
2001-2437:
Mash v. Prolease - 03/13/2002
2001-2437:
Mash v. Prolease - 01/31/2003
2001-2437:
Mash v. Prolease - 08/07/2006
2001-2443:
Miller v. Aetna - 12/13/2001
2001-2448:
Nicola v. Piscitelli - 04/08/2002
2001-2476:
Jones v. Aetna Life - 08/14/2002
2001-2478:
Strozyk v. Norfolk - 06/05/2002
2001-2511:
Lambert v. Blackwell - 11/21/2001
2001-2511:
Lambert v. Blackwell - 01/18/2002
2001-2511:
Lambert v. Blackwell - 04/01/2003
2001-2514:
Rosenberg v. Vangelo - 04/18/2002
2001-2520:
Dianese v. Commonwealth of PA - 02/27/2002
2001-2520:
Dianese v. Commonwealth of PA - 02/27/2002
2001-2520:
Dianese v. Commonwealth of PA - 02/27/2002
2001-2520:
Dianese v. Commonwealth of PA - 06/18/2002
2001-2539:
Todi v. Stursberg - 08/02/2001
2001-2539:
Todi v. Stursberg - 12/04/2001
2001-2541:
In Re: ATI Technologies - 07/23/2002
2001-2541:
In Re: ATI Technologies - 04/28/2003
2001-2564:
Hitchens v. Montgomery County - 02/12/2002
2001-2578:
Oliphant-Jones v. Philadelphia - 12/13/2002
2001-2579:
Ross v. Kyler - 02/05/2002
2001-2582:
Rodriguez v. Barnhart - 03/11/2003
2001-2586:
Meshkov v. Unum - 07/08/2002
2001-2587:
Marcelus v. I.N.S. - 01/16/2002
2001-2593:
Graham v. Philadelphia - 07/17/2002
2001-2596:
Reilly Foam v. Rubbermaid - 05/28/2002
2001-2600:
Sangmeister v. Airborne - 08/30/2001
2001-2624:
Bond v. Blaine - 04/25/2006
2001-2626:
Bonin v. World Umpires - 10/16/2001
2001-2627:
Mertz v. Houston - 07/31/2001
2001-2650:
American Equipment v. Capital - 07/11/2002
2001-2655:
Wright v. Philadelphia - 10/02/2001
2001-2666:
Fiberlink v. Digital - 07/18/2002
2001-2678:
Purcell v. Universal Bank - 04/28/2003
2001-2679:
Joseph v. Ashcroft - 08/05/2002
2001-2682:
Arcila v. Christopher Trucking - 04/18/2002
2001-2683:
Speciality Ring v. MHF - 11/15/2001
2001-0007: Pazos v. Lyondell - 12/21/2001